The Heart of a Green Home: The HVAC System

Bloomington Hollyhocks
Originally uploaded by cgulyas2002
We are finalizing plans for our high-performance home in Bloomington, Indiana, and received this email from our Energy Modeler and Home Engineer, Marko Spiegel.
David,
I'm enclosing a number of pdf files, some of them RemRate summaries, and one of them my summary. Here is the conclusion:a. All electric at $0.065 is the most economical way to heat and equip your house - least capital and least annual cost
b. air source heat pumps will do the trick and all alternatives and not economically justifiable - if you guys were economists - not passionate promoters of sustainability
c. The #1 energy saving measure you guys do is dramatically lowering all loads - therefore all paybacks of high tech solutions look really questionable
d. Of all the renewable energy options and combinations the ground source heat pump in combination with 2.5kW Solar PV is of course the best - it achieves HERS17!!! - and lots of bragging rights
e. Air source heat pump and 2.5kW Solar PV get you at least to HERS 29- not bad at all
If you asked me what I would do given the major difference in cost: I would choose the simplest HVAC system using air source heat pump to start out with and add PV once the house is complete and you guys are comfortable in your situation. An on-demand electrical water heater from Stiebel Eltron costs max. $500.-/piece. PV will address ALL your loads and keeps your systems simple. Simple is a big part of our design goal."
What combination would YOU choose?








